The Limits of Charm in Business

By Bryan Orr

We all know people that have walked up to you, and you just want them to like you. They have a certain mystique or magnetism that quickly disarms any cynicism you may have about them.

I’m not talking about the used car salesman type who talks fast and keeps trying to “close the deal.” Those people are the opposite of the person I’m talking about. This person doesn’t need to ask you to buy from them. You may even find yourself asking them when and how you can buy from them.

When you meet someone like that you are in the presence of a “charming” personality.

Charming means likable, pleasant and attractive but it also means that “to gain influence over,” which is to say that, not only do you find yourself drawn to the charming person, you may come under their influence.

Charm is a valuable asset at all levels of business and personal life. It’s a nuanced ability, and as much a valuable skill as anything else you’ve learned. Heck, there’s even a podcast called “The Art Charm” that focuses on charm as a skill set. If you’re naturally a “charmer,” sure. Many aren’t, and learning this skill will help you.

Learning usually starts by observing people who already have it and emulating them. Humans are creatures of observation and habit, we see things in other people and we begin to act like them over time. You pick up “charming” traits by spending time with charming people.

In my first full time job, I worked for a manager that I looked up to. He spoke with just a touch of country “twang” and before long, I found myself emulating his management style as well as his twang. I still find it comes out in my voice as a completely involuntary reaction to people with that accent. Unless I’m with my wife. I don’t get too far with it before my wife points it out and makes fun of me.

But there is a limit.

While charm may be one of the best tools to get your foot in the door, or even to make that first sale it is not THE BEST tool.

Charm is a “stage-setter.” It influences how a new customer will view your actual abilities, but at the end of the day, it will be your actual abilities that earn a customer’s long-term trust. This is why some business types and segments focus on charm and others focus on execution and reputation. It all depends on the length of the business cycle and the type of transaction.

This is why the automobile sales industry has the reputation it has. All charm, very little substance. There is little repeat business, so the immediate impression has much more value than the long-term confidence from any technical automotive-related knowledge or skills.

On the opposite side of the spectrum would be business to business service providers who have huge contracts with relatively few large customers. There is no way Exxon / Mobile or Walmart are going to ink a multi-million dollar deal with a vendor unless they have a REASON to believe there is substance behind the charm. That trust typically comes from FACTS: Hard skills and proven execution.

In service businesses, your work typically has a payoff in repeat business, either with that particular customer, or with friends that were connected to you by that customer. Being that guy that, they “liked a lot, but didn’t really know what he was doing,” isn’t going to get you many repeat services. Charm is valuable, but unlike technical expertise, cannot carry a long-term business cycle on its own. Being the guy that “Grunted a couple times, but went right in, and it just worked,” is a far better recommendation, if it comes down to one or the other.

More often than not those that rise to the top and achieve excellence start with either charm or execution and learn the other side of the coin as they grow. They can get a new customer by turning on the charm but they, build the business by substance and the reputation that comes along with it.

It’s important to be charming, it’s even better to be dependable.

Picture of Chaz Michaels

Chaz Michaels

TRENDING AROUND THE WEB

People who deliberately pick up books outside the genre they already gravitate toward aren’t just diversifying a hobby; they’re giving themselves regular practice at understanding unfamiliar structure and vocabulary instead of relying on a comfort zone that stopped stretching them a while ago.

People who deliberately pick up books outside the genre they already gravitate toward aren’t just diversifying a hobby; they’re giving themselves regular practice at understanding unfamiliar structure and vocabulary instead of relying on a comfort zone that stopped stretching them a while ago.

Global English Editing

Beehiiv just gave newsletter subscribers a way to talk to each other, and it’s a hedge against the one thing that makes newsletter platforms replaceable

Beehiiv just gave newsletter subscribers a way to talk to each other, and it’s a hedge against the one thing that makes newsletter platforms replaceable

The Blog Herald

The older some people get, the shorter their messages become — and that isn’t always impatience, sometimes it’s the confidence to say only what they mean

The older some people get, the shorter their messages become — and that isn’t always impatience, sometimes it’s the confidence to say only what they mean

Global English Editing

The Ankler didn’t leave Substack for a bigger audience – it left because the 10% cut that works at newsletter scale stops working at media-company scale

The Ankler didn’t leave Substack for a bigger audience – it left because the 10% cut that works at newsletter scale stops working at media-company scale

The Blog Herald

“I don’t want to talk about it” doesn’t necessarily mean someone won’t communicate, psychologists who study a pattern known as normative male alexithymia have found many men are socialized from childhood to have a genuinely thinner emotional vocabulary to reach for, not a refusal to use the one they have.

“I don’t want to talk about it” doesn’t necessarily mean someone won’t communicate, psychologists who study a pattern known as normative male alexithymia have found many men are socialized from childhood to have a genuinely thinner emotional vocabulary to reach for, not a refusal to use the one they have.

Global English Editing

Virginia’s mandatory one-hour daily limit on teen social media use was struck down by a federal judge less than two months after it took effect, and NetChoice’s First Amendment win over Virginia’s usage caps could stall similar bills in other statehouses that would have limited how publishers reach younger audiences.

Virginia’s mandatory one-hour daily limit on teen social media use was struck down by a federal judge less than two months after it took effect, and NetChoice’s First Amendment win over Virginia’s usage caps could stall similar bills in other statehouses that would have limited how publishers reach younger audiences.

The Blog Herald

Subscribe to receive our latest articles!

Get updates on the latest posts and more from Small Business Bonfire straight to your inbox.